|
1. Q. According to our story, why was Reuven at fault?
A. Since Reuven
blocked the road, he's at fault.
2.
Q. On what point do Reuven and Shimon agree?
A. That
if Reuven blocks the whole road, he's at fault.
3.
Q. Why isn't Reuven exempt from payment of
damages, even though Shimon had room to pass?
A. Reuven must take into consideration that Shimon may
have limited visibility; for example, Shimon may be absorbed in his task.
4.
Q. What is the position of Tosefot?
A. If
Shimon has room to pass, Reuven
is exempt from payment of damages.
5.
Q. What is the position of the Rambam?
A. Reuven is at fault for blocking, even partially, the
road.
6.
Q. What is the Shulchan Aruch
Choshen Mishpat's
decision?
A. Reuven must pay for damages even if there was room
for Shimon to pass, unless Reuven warned Shimon.
|
