|
"There was a synagogue of Jews from Rome that was
open to a room with a corpse and the Cohanim could not enter
the synagogue to pray. They went and told Rava. He told them
to lift up the ark and put it between the two rooms because
the ark is a wooden utensil that is made to stay in one place
and therefore does not become TAMAY (ritually impure) and
can be a partition that the TUMAH will not pass through. The
other Rabbis told Rava that sometimes the ark is carried around
with the Torah Scroll on it. Rava then replied to the Cohanim
that he has no solution (and must pray somewhere else)."
There are several categories of things which
are TAMAY. None of them have the capability of causing the
TUMAH to pass to something else unless it is touched or carried
- except one*. A corpse or a piece of a corpse is TAMAY and
can transfer its TUMAH throughout a house and into the next
house as long as they are under one roof. If they are under
one roof but in separate rooms, if there is a window between
them as big as a hand-breadth, so the two rooms are filled
with TUMAH and a Jew who is a COHEN is forbidden to enter
either room. One way around the problem is to plug up the
window. Then the Cohen can enter the room without the corpse.
However not every plug will work. For instance, plugging it
with a handkerchief or pieces of bread will not work.
Another way around it is to cover the window
with a utensil - but the utensil must be incapable of becoming
TAMAY. There are rules to these things. One rule is that anything
which is sometimes empty and sometimes full that can be moved
only when empty - is not able to be TAMAY. The example might
be a portable bath-tub that when filled is too heavy to move.
Rava thought the ark of the synagogue was never
moved when the Torah Scroll was on it. Therefore he concluded
that the ark could not become TAMAY and could be placed next
to the window between the rooms and block the hole. The other
Rabbis informed him that he was incorrect in his assumption
since the ark was sometimes moved when "full". Rava
switched his opinion and told the Cohanim that he had no solution
to their problem.
The truth is that if we had more information
about the size and placement of the window between the rooms
and if we had materials on hand to plug it up, we could succeed
in fixing up the place for the Cohanim to pray. However, the
story related by the gemorrah should be understood as I explained
above.
* I should mention that there are cases of Zaraas that transfer
TUMAH under one roof. I have reasons for not discussing that
point now.
|